RAMajd's daily notes

Notes about challenges I face during my day to day work

VCPKG Property Group issue with MSBuild

When using vcpkg with Visual Studio 2022, some developers have reported issues with vcpkg overriding project properties set within Visual Studio projects. This article summarizes the root cause and potential resolutions, based on discussions in Github issue #27906.

vcpkg-msbuild.png

1. The Problem

The problem arises when vcpkg’s settings, defined in the vcxproj file, take precedence over the Visual Studio project properties. This can lead to unexpected behavior during the build process, as the project-specific configurations may not be applied correctly.

1.1. Key Observations

  1. The issue is specific to certain configurations where vcpkg property groups are evaluated after the project’s configuration properties.
  2. This sequencing causes vcpkg’s settings to override properties that the developer intended to prioritize.

2. Root Cause

The root cause lies in the order of property evaluation in MSBuild. In the typical MSBuild process:

  • Properties are evaluated in sequence based on the order defined in the build files.
  • If vcpkg property groups introduces settings after the project definitions, they might override user-defined properties unless explicitly handled.

3. Suggested Resolution

To address this issue, developers should:

  1. Review the vcxproj File: Examine the order of property group definitions and imports.
  2. Ensure Proper Overrides: Use the Condition attribute in property definitions to ensure that user-defined properties are not overridden unintentionally.

    <PropertyGroup Label="Vcpkg" Condition="'$(YourProperty)' == ''">
       <YourProperty>DefaultValue</YourProperty>
    </PropertyGroup>
    
  3. Modify Project Files: Explicitly set project-specific properties in a way that ensures they are applied after vcpkg’s settings.

    <PropertyGroup Label="Vcpkg" Condition="'$(YourProperty)' == ''">
       <YourProperty>DefaultValue</YourProperty>
    </PropertyGroup>
    ...
    <Import Project="$(VCTargetPath)\Microsot.Cpp.targets" />
    ...
    

4. Conclusion

This issue highlights the importance of understanding MSBuild’s property evaluation mechanism, especially when integrating third-party tools like vcpkg. By carefully managing the order of property evaluations and using conditions, developers can ensure their Visual Studio project properties are applied as intended.